Apple Inc
AAPL
$141.61
(+1.93%)
Alphabet Inc - Class C
GOOG
$2,279.07
(+4.47%)
Alphabet Inc - Class A
GOOGL
$2,266.72
(+4.23%)
Amazon.com Inc.
AMZN
$113.51
(+3.55%)
Microsoft Corporation
MSFT
$262.91
(+1.28%)
Meta Platforms Inc - Class A
FB
$196.64
(+0.51%)
Berkshire Hathaway Inc. - Class B
BRK.B
$275.69
(-0.65%)
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd - ADR
BABA
$120.13
(+3.56%)
JPMorgan Chase & Co.
JPM
$112.62
(-1.25%)
Johnson & Johnson
JNJ
$178.14
(-0.77%)
Bank Of America Corp.
BAC
$31.24
(-1.01%)
Exxon Mobil Corp.
XOM
$84.81
(-3.13%)
Wells Fargo & Co.
WFC
$40.10
(+0.45%)
Visa Inc - Class A
V
$200.54
(+0.68%)
Walmart Inc
WMT
$124.25
(+1.32%)
Shell Plc - ADR
RDS.B
$51.06
(0%)
Shell Plc - ADR (Representing Ordinary Shares - Class A)
RDS.A
$51.04
(0%)
Intel Corp.
INTC
$36.72
(+1.05%)
AT&T, Inc.
T
$21.17
(-0.66%)
Unitedhealth Group Inc
UNH
$505.24
(-2.35%)
Cisco Systems, Inc.
CSCO
$41.97
(-1.48%)
PetroChina Co. Ltd. - ADR
PTR
$44.47
(-6.08%)
Novartis AG - ADR
NVS
$84.28
(-0.1%)
Pfizer Inc.
PFE
$51.64
(-1.28%)
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing - ADR
TSM
$76.11
(-1.16%)
Toyota Motor Corporation - ADR
TM
$154.67
(-0.52%)
Home Depot, Inc.
HD
$283.73
(+1.67%)
Oracle Corp.
ORCL
$71.99
(+1.58%)
Boeing Co.
BA
$137.70
(-1.53%)
Procter & Gamble Co.
PG
$144.70
(-0.97%)
Verizon Communications Inc
VZ
$51.42
(-0.43%)
Citigroup Inc
C
$46.61
(-0.56%)
HSBC Holdings plc - ADR
HSBC
$31.61
(-3.27%)
China Mobile Limited - ADR
CHL
$27.51
(0%)
Coca-Cola Co
KO
$63.28
(-1.71%)
Anheuser-Busch In Bev SA/NV - ADR
BUD
$54.63
(-0.82%)
Mastercard Incorporated - Class A
MA
$319.26
(+0.32%)
Abbvie Inc
ABBV
$153.93
(+0.09%)
Comcast Corp - Class A
CMCSA
$39.83
(-1.14%)
Philip Morris International Inc
PM
$98.08
(-1.65%)
Walt Disney Co (The)
DIS
$97.18
(+1.08%)
PepsiCo Inc
PEP
$169.04
(-0.21%)
Unilever NV
UN
$60.50
(0%)
Unilever plc - ADR
UL
$45.84
(-0.97%)
Merck & Co Inc
MRK
$92.64
(+0.24%)
NVIDIA Corp
NVDA
$149.66
(+3.05%)
International Business Machines Corp.
IBM
$137.62
(-2.48%)
3M Co.
MMM
$129.21
(+0.56%)
No Result
View All Result
The New York Ledger
  • Home
  • News

    Boris Johnson on the brink after Rishi Sunak and Sajid Javid quit UK cabinet

    France repatriates children and mothers from Syrian camps

    Alternate-Side Parking Is Back in Full Force: ‘It’s a Pain in the Neck’

    Israel needs to break the cycle of elections

    After Another Mass Shooting, New Jersey Tightens Gun Laws

    Chicago suburb officials say gunman had been planning massacre ‘for several weeks’

    Trending Tags

    • general news
    • Risk News
    • Political/General News
    • industrial news
    • Travel
    • Financial Crime
    • business
    • consumer services
  • Spotlight
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Markets
  • Companies
  • Tech
  • Climate
  • Lifestyle
Subscribe
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News

    Boris Johnson on the brink after Rishi Sunak and Sajid Javid quit UK cabinet

    France repatriates children and mothers from Syrian camps

    Alternate-Side Parking Is Back in Full Force: ‘It’s a Pain in the Neck’

    Israel needs to break the cycle of elections

    After Another Mass Shooting, New Jersey Tightens Gun Laws

    Chicago suburb officials say gunman had been planning massacre ‘for several weeks’

    Trending Tags

    • general news
    • Risk News
    • Political/General News
    • industrial news
    • Travel
    • Financial Crime
    • business
    • consumer services
  • Spotlight
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Markets
  • Companies
  • Tech
  • Climate
  • Lifestyle
Subscribe
  • Login
The New York Ledger
No Result
View All Result
Home Companies

Collective pensions: there’s little protection in the crowd

June 23, 2022
in Companies
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Defined benefit pensions, where an employer guarantees a pension for life, are almost extinct in the private sector. Defined contribution schemes, where people draw a pension from their individual pot and take their own investment and longevity risk, are now standard.

Some people claim “collective defined contribution” (CDC) pensions are a middle way between defined benefit (DB) and individual defined contribution (DC) schemes. CDC sets an annual “target pension”, based on member and employer contributions. Target pensions, including pensions in payment, move up or down each year, in line with the value of assets.

Guy Opperman, pensions minister, is certainly a fan, saying recently that CDC could “transform the UK pensions landscape and deliver better retirement outcomes for millions of pension savers”. The government has also just published a consultation on how multiemployer CDC could work. Is Opperman right?

So far, only Royal Mail has said it will start CDC for its 140,000 staff — part of a deal agreed in 2018 to see off threatened strikes — and it has lobbied hard for new legislation.

Royal Mail’s CDC scheme will have employer and employee contributions of 15.2 per cent of salary, which it says produces a target pension of 1/80th of salary, from age 67, with annual increases of inflation plus 1 per cent.

Over 40 years a member could expect a target pension of half average salary, 50 per cent higher than an individual DC saver could expect, for the same contributions and investment returns. It looks like collective DC is a clear winner. What’s not to like?

But Royal Mail’s CDC forecast is much higher than individual DC because its asset allocation is much riskier — an astonishing 100 per cent equities — than a typical individual DC.

“Higher risk equals higher expected return” is true, but is not very helpful in thinking about better retirement outcomes.

Fans say CDC captures expected long-term equity returns, with lower risk than individual DC, thanks to “intergenerational risk-sharing”, but explanations of how this works are notoriously vague.

Take an individual DC saver with a £100,000 pot, 100 per cent in equities. If the value of the pot falls by 20 per cent, then the forecast pension, including inflation increases, also falls by 20 per cent.

What about a CDC scheme with 10,000 members and £500mn of assets, 100 per cent equities? If assets fall by 20 per cent, then forecast pensions, including inflation increases, fall by 20 per cent — just like individual DC.

Although the 10,000 members have different retirement dates, this does not smooth outcomes. If assets fall by 20 per cent in a year then the value of the target pension, including annual increases, for a 90-year-old, 80-year-old or 70-year-old pensioner, all fall by 20 per cent.

The value of the target pension, including annual increases, for the 60-, 50- or 40-year-old not yet retired, also goes down 20 per cent, even though they will retire on different dates.

Expected returns and risk are identical whether equities are held in an individual or collective DC. And the actual annual return, whatever it is, means the same change to forecast individual DC or collective DC pensions. For any identical level of contributions and investment risk, collective and individual DC outcomes are identical.

If an individual DC saver wants a higher expected return, they can simply hold more equities. If they are happy with the risk of 100 per cent equities, their forecast pension will be identical to Royal Mail CDC.

Individual DC has the killer advantage that each saver can choose their own asset allocation, to suit their personal risk preferences, which probably changes as they get older. But CDC asset allocation is identical for all members, regardless of age or risk preference, so will be “suboptimal” for virtually all of them. Some will prefer more investment risk, some less.

Communicating pension information is crucial in getting people to make better decisions about how much to save, when they can afford to stop working, and how much they will get in retirement.

By definition, both individual and collective DC pensions are DC, so member communications should include exactly the same information.

Annual individual DC statements are required to show the opening value, contributions, and closing value. Collective DC statements should be the same: the opening cash transfer value — how much the member can withdraw to move to another pension — contributions, and closing cash transfer value. How the value of DC assets has changed — individual and collective — must be crystal clear.

Individual DC statements also forecast the size of annuity, or guaranteed pension, which could be bought at retirement, and collective DC statements should show this too.

Individual DC statements are not required to forecast the inflation-adjusted pension if a saver chooses not to buy an annuity but moves into drawdown. This should be required for both individual and collective DC.

This may all seem uncontroversial, but the CDC communication requirements, set out by the government and pensions regulator, are weak, and will create a smokescreen.

DC pensions — whether individual or collective — can only be paid from contributions and investment returns. If contributions and asset allocation are identical, then “retirement outcomes” for individual and collective DC must also be identical.

Unfortunately, focusing on shiny new CDC schemes diverts public policy energy from the less glamorous job of improving how individual DC pensions work.

John Ralfe is an independent pension consultant. Twitter: @johnralfe1



Source: Financial Times

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Companies

CureVac sues BioNTech over mRNA patents

Companies

BA flight cancellations and refuelling strikes set to bring more travel chaos

Companies

Bank of England warns UK economic outlook has ‘deteriorated markedly’

Companies

BYD/Tesla: China’s carmakers gain ground as profitability is stretched

Companies

SAS files for bankruptcy protection as pilot strike grounds flights

Companies

Sainsbury’s sales fall as customers cut back spending

Companies

First female chair of Herbert Smith Freehills says flexible working made role attractive

Companies

Warren Buffett-backed Chinese group BYD overtakes Tesla in global electric vehicle sales

Companies

Defence group chief urges lending shake-up at European Investment Bank

Popular News

  • DOJ’s big crypto crackdown

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • This $20 Device Turns a Handgun Into an Automatic Weapon

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Brussels pushes for tougher sanctions enforcement via EU-wide body

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Humanities degrees: ave atque vale

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • KPMG’s business in UAE split by partner infighting and coup attempt

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Latest News

Politics

DC public schools hosts racially segregated ‘affinity groups’ for staff

News

Boris Johnson on the brink after Rishi Sunak and Sajid Javid quit UK cabinet

Companies

CureVac sues BioNTech over mRNA patents

Markets

Norway government halts oil and gas strike

About Us

The New York Ledger is an online newspaper for cosmopolitans, global entrepreneurs, management staff, influencers, and other modern leaders who care about wider aspects and broader opinions.

Category

  • Business
  • Climate
  • Companies
  • Lifestyle
  • Markets
  • News
  • Politics
  • Spotlight
  • Tech

Topics

2020 Election 2021) Biomass Ultima Donald Trump global warming Project Phoenix8 Proud Boys Roberto Hroval Themis Ecosystem your-feed-visual-investigations
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact

© 2021 All Rights Reserved - Blue Planet Global Media Network

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Spotlight
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Markets
  • Companies
  • Tech
  • Climate
  • Lifestyle

© 2021 All Rights Reserved - Blue Planet Global Media Network

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.